firstly its worth noting that the two main reasons for people posting on hardware specific forums is:
1. To complain
2. To ask for information about doing something
Except for the odd email (usually in reply to a complaint), people don't write in to say everthing is going well. Which means that given the device is selling 1000s, there is little complaint (look at ipod lounge for the treble distortion issue on seriers 3 ipods to see what I mean).
I personnaly think the E61 is a breakthrough device. I have had plenty of PDAs (see below) and I know none that have all the following features:
1. Sync. with Blackberry Connect
2. Sync. with MS Exchange
3. Light
4. Decent Battery life
5. Thin and fits in shirt pocket
6. Made of aluminium and steel and plastic. Feels robust
7. Fantastic screen.
8. Usable keyboard
9. Small
10. Best mobile browser
11. Takes memory cards (miniSD)
12. Sync. With notes & outlook seemlessly out of the box (my diary is work notes, contacts are home outlook)
13. Wifi
14. 3G
15, Edge
16. VOIP SIP stack - Truphone works very well
17. Loads of software bundled free (inc. cool golf game)
18. Opens and edits word & excel docs
19. Displays adobe and ppt
20. Loads of software available (handango, symbiangear, etc.)
21. Usable joystick
22. Fast menu button and task switcher (unlike WM5)
23. Yes, its faster then WM5 (with static memory problem). Need v2 software to find out
24. Symbian designed to conserve battery
25. Can install apps entirely on mem card (not like WM5 which still buggers with registry)
26. Power phone hard codec links embedded in kernel. Truphone sounds great
27. Easy to use (except for a complete muppet - they tend to like Palm 😊
28. Easy to write apps requiring data stream
I could go on, but you know the drill.
as for Palm:
1. File system is primitive and does not support full frame video etc.
2. No serious add on apps, tons of lightweight games
3. OS has problem with streaming. No voip or other apps written for it.
4. Palm OS has run out of breath. Its time is numbered. Its capabilities are limited. Even Treos are going to Win Mobile.
as for WM:
Functionality Windows mobile is great, but except on the excellent HTC smartphones (with OMAP) the battery goes quickly. and WM5 has alot of glitches to be sorted out. And its slowwwww
as for RIM:
is a one trick pony. Email is good but PDA, browser, available apps and UI is pants. The Blackberry 8100/Pearl is the best attempt by RIM. Its great as a phone and using bb email. But the app, browser and compatability problems remain.
It terms of a mere sample of my previous PDAs:
HTC Universal, HTC Hurricane, HTC Tornado, Nokia 9300i, Dell Axim x50v, Mio 201, Blackberry 7100, Treo 600, Sony clie, etc, etc. So I have used them all.
In summary IMHO E61 is breakthrough device for people who need to stay connected.
a. Small and light
b. I sync my diary with work and my contacts with home
c. My free MSN client is great (HIER)
d. Truphone VOIP for (zero!) cheap international calls to landlines
e. Cool games
f. Oh yes, it works great as a phone.
Yes it would be great to have the cpu running at 250Mhz instead of 150Mhz, but I prefer the battery life. It only really effects me when opening apps. Once running they are speedy. And Yes, the Palm interface is easier for the first 4 minutes of usage!
Its just a pity the cell structure in the US is so fragmented. And cingular has killed Wifi on the E62 just for their own reasons.
Have to go, got an email ......😎