Read-only archive of the All About Symbian forum (2001–2013) · About this archive

Some mobile phone hardware suggestions

19 replies · 4,087 views · Started 20 November 2008

Every so often you find yourself in a situation where you wish "If only my phone could do this..." because it lacks the necessary hardware for a task. In a perhaps slightly tongue-in-cheek editorial, AAS takes a look at hardware features which are not available on modern mobile phones but perhaps should be. As always comments are very welcome in the thread below, especially your own suggestions for potentially useful phone features.

Read on in the full article.

I want a blu-ray burner into my phone.
.
.
Apart childish jokes.
The features i have always wanted.....and suggested nokia 2 years ago before the nokia n95 release in competion in order to win one of this milestone....but not won..
'THE POSSIBILITY TO RECORD FROM RADIO IN MP3'
.
.
'Audio and Video Chat'_hope the talented guys of Lonely Cat Games make it through with their new awsome Slick'

I hope people post stuff other than asking for a bigger megapixel camera or optical zoom or standard xenon flash :tongue:

I have a very simple request (this already exists in WM phones) - LED indicators. Its very handy if you have some sort of tiny light flashing on the top of your phone to indicate minor things like you have a missed call or you have a new message or your bluetooth is on, etc.

Video calls over wifi - I dont think the telephone companies will allow a video call that is divided between voice on their network and video on another (wifi) network. Yes, video chat over IM clients like MSN/yahoo/google would be awesome. I dont think this will be that difficult. You can already chat over IM clients using apps like fring.

Oh what I wouldn't give for an FM aerial on my phone. I use Bluetooth headphones and so the radio is a feature I never use even though I'd very much like to (though not enough to put up with wires and poor-quality sound from the earphones that came in the box).
I agree a telescopic aerial is very old-skool (although Japanese ISDB-T and Korean DMB TV phones use them!) and presumably wouldn't be any use while the phone's in your pocket but perhaps someone will find a way to shrink the FM aerial enough to be built into the phone.
I don't know much about radio transmissions, but it seems to me that if they can produce an integrated FM transmitter (a la N78) they ought to be able to make an integrated FM receiver too.

As for powering the phone - butane batteries are still under development, but that would be a nice one to see. Or, how about a clock-work battery top-up - if they can do it with radios then surely a phone is not going to be rocket-science.

ILG

The stylus on touch screen phones could double as an aerial.
_________________
symbian.site666.info

Video calls over wifi - I dont think the telephone companies will allow a video call that is divided between voice on their network and video on another (wifi) network.

Sorry, I should have made this clearer in the article: by "wi-fi video call" I don't really mean a phone network videophone call, but a video call through a totally separate non-phone service.

For example Skype on computers offers video calling, as does Google Talk on Nokia internet tablets, so either of these services could (technically) be implemented on wi-fi-compatible smartphones. That's what I'm suggesting, basically.

Oh what I wouldn't give for an FM aerial on my phone.

Just had a thought on that, too late to add it to the article but here it is anyway:

If DVB-H television channels can be received on a phone without an external aerial, could radio stations be sent as part of the DVB-H multiplex?

Of course you'd need a DVB-H phone to do this, but perhaps it will become a standard feature one day?

I hope people post stuff other than asking for a bigger megapixel camera or optical zoom or standard xenon flash

Yeah, those features are already available on some models, so if people really want them they can get them.

Or, how about a clock-work battery top-up - if they can do it with radios then surely a phone is not going to be rocket-science.

Good idea, especially for people in remote or poor areas without access to a power source. The "$100 laptop" has a wind-up charging system for exactly that reason, and of course the massive success of wind-up radios in developing countries is well known.

Come to think of it, I'm fairly sure a third party manufacturer has actually released a wind-up phone battery charger, can't remember its name though!

the most annoying thing for me about blackberries and WM devices is the flashing LED's (forcing your eye to them).
The gentle pulse of the E71 (which i hope can be turned off), is much more pleasant, if you need something other than the indicators on the home screen.

Hardware extensions:
- an included FM aerial, that could use the headphone cord to improve reception, i.e. it only gets the very strongest signals without the headphones being plugged in.
- TV/VGA out
- USB master, so that hard disks, external keyboards, mice etc can be used.

For me it is more about software improvements:
- PIM sync at least as good as Palm used to be;
* Configurable so that if there is clash, there would be choices like; make me decide which one is correct or newest wins or PC or phone is always master etc
* multiple calendars, multiple note categories etc
- built in office suite at a functionality & quality level like Psion had
- synchronisation of text files in a folder between PC and phone

This one will need more power, but I would love a phone that could stand on the desk, projecting it's high-resolution image on to a flat surface of your choice, while it also projects an infra-red full-size querty keyboard on to the desk in front of you...all this while giving you a back-rub 😉

ILG

This one will need more power, but I would love a phone that could stand on the desk, projecting it's high-resolution image on to a flat surface of your choice
Maybe this can work through a portable projector connected to the phone through the miniusb port...

A reel type aerial will be more practical. Or perhaps pull out notch-type head phones with reel-out/in mechanism would be more smart, that way you don't need to carry the head phones separately.

An AM radio - so that I can listen to the sport! (without relying on streaming).

DAB maybe?

A compass.

HD video capture capability - ie faster processer require I guess

There are endless software improvements possible, but those are the hardware ones I can think of

I have a very simple request (this already exists in WM phones) - LED indicators. Its very handy if you have some sort of tiny light flashing on the top of your phone to indicate minor things like you have a missed call or you have a new message or your bluetooth is on, etc.

Yep. Two of my female colleagues have stuck with v old silver clamshell Nokias that flash when you've got a txt or missed a call because they (like many women) keep their phones in their handbags so frequently don't hear the ringtone in noisy environments and obviously wouldn't feel the phone vibrating when switched to silent at work as its not in their pocket (where most men keep theirs I'll wager). Really simple thing, but noone seems to be offering this functionality any more.

A quick glance down into a handbag takes a lot less time than pulling out the phone, pressing two buttons to unlock and then having to repeat to put the phone away.

Extra bonus: apparently it's a lot easier to do the glancing thing surrepticiously several times when you've been stood up at a bar without everyone else in the place knowing 😊

how about a small solar plate on the back panel which enables us to recharge in sun without any wire tangles or proporta.

Actually the old 3300 had the ability to record radio to mp3 and also record through an audio cable.
This gave me an idea, why not TV-in. Ie the ability to connect the phone to a tv and then record what's on to mp4 files. Obviously there are licensing issues that probably prevent copying from radio as well but surely nokia could overcome them. Vcr's were around for years and nowadays anything is downloadable (albeit illegally). Another way of looking at it is this. I can either video tape one of my favorite tv episodes with poor quality, or simply plug in the phone to get perfect quality.
Come on nokia show some guts for the sake of user experience. And throw out drm while you at it.

The N78 and similar phones have the glowing Naviwheel to indicate the message arrival. It is not a complete equivalent for a sidelight. At least a compromise 😊

err how about a 3d graphics chip, oh and used for once!!

Obviously there are licensing issues that probably prevent copying from radio as well but surely nokia could overcome them.

I can't see any legal problems about recording onto a phone from the radio or television, as long as you're the only one who can view or listen to the recording.

Video recorders connected to TVs have been legal for 30 years now, and tape recorders connected to radios have been legal for even longer. Distributing those recordings to others is illegal, but recording purely for personal use (as a form of time-shifting) is totally okay in the eyes of the law.

"TV In" sounds like a very good idea, tape a programme and then take it with you to watch on the train. That's no different to recording something on a PVR or video recorder, just a lot more portable.

I have a very simple request (this already exists in WM phones) - LED indicators. Its very handy if you have some sort of tiny light flashing on the top of your phone to indicate minor things like you have a missed call or you have a new message or your bluetooth is on, etc.

That already exists on quite a number of phones AFAIK, usually the ones that have e-mail as a major selling point.

It's also on some budget phones such as the Nokia 7070, with a light that flashes to indicate a missed message or call on the outside of the clamshell.