Hi Dazz - I agree with all your comments - when the battery works, after some consumer input to setup the handset from all the tweaks you can read off the 'net, it is GREAT -
the main issue is, what happens if you are someone e.g. a professional, who requires his handset to be on all the time, even when it is charging, so you don't miss a call.?
Perhaps also you are someone who doesn't even have time to remember to reboot his telephone every day? Currently I am not someone such as this, but I have been...
Every other handset I have owned has not had this problem, bar an Orange SPV, which became known for battery drain via its SD card slot (with an SD card in, a background process started up & drained the battery much quicker).
As an update, as of this morning, I am at a loss as to what is causing this problem - as my i8910 suffered it again last night for really obscure reasons - this is what happened:
I turned off the handset and charged it up yesterday evening, taking it off the charger at 23:00, fully charged after at least 4h. I turned it on (to test) and left it on. Now, most nights, if I do this, knowing I had not used the handset (it was on a fresh reboot before I went to bed) then I should be ok! In fact, at 07.15 I was awakened by the 'low battery' beep! So, in fact, the battery had drained as if I had been watching an .mp4 all night! BUT, the handset had not been touched and the screen never activated!
Now, what had changed?
The only thing that had happened in the night is that I had received an SMS from an overseas friend at about 1 a.m. which I had not heard as I leave my handset in silent mode.
So,
Is the battery drain problem
a) due to the Messaging app?
b) due to the USB sync cable that when connected to PC studio - but I have found starts up 3 additional apps (from the 12 initially reported by PhoNetInfo) two of which are a Clock process - and, yes, a Messaging process!!! - as XP-based PC studio program shows you on the PC screen your new SMSs!
or it could be:
c) no-one else can relate to these problems as I am the only one with a faulty handset in this regard...(?)
So, do I have what you would call a faulty handset? (I think I do) Has anyone out there actually 'nailed' this problem with a practical workaround yet, that doesn't involve leaving the handset switched off ?
I have Orange UK firmware xxIE2 - not debranded because a) I am not sure of warranty implications and b) I have not had the time to properly research this to ensure a low risk re: I don't damage the handset and can put back on the Orange firmware too - and c) I am now waiting for the possible elixir of the two possible firmware updates from Samsung, assuming somehow a UK user can get them on his/her i8910, and that one contains a fix for this battery issue.
So it remains, my workaround will be to leave the handset switched off overnight completely and/or have my spare battery ready to be put in, if my main one drains.
- but for others who may be reading this, this might not be a great situation! (e.g. you might actually want to use the handset at all times). I also found (see above post) that if this battery drain process is actually going on in your handset, then charging your handset whilst it is on results in poor overall charging - i.e. in 4h you will not get a full charge, but rather a 30% charge, then after you stop charging, of course, your battery goes down in 3h again.
Conclusion: I believe now that at least one way this battery drain phenomenon on my xxIE2 (6 May 2009) Orange UK firmware i8910 might be somehow caused is through a Messaging app process, likely activated e.g. by an incoming SMS.
Comments welcomed!
Is there any program out there I don't have to pay for that will allow me to find and 'kill' this Messaging process I see through PhoNetInfo, so I can test my findings above? I don't want to pay, as I might eventually have to return the handset and give up on this incredibly buggy Symbian handset altogether and get back to happier WinMo hunting grounds. But I haven't given up, not quite yet, but I am very close to this decision (sorry everyone)!
I also have not yet fully understood this Symbian signing nonsense. a) I don't want to get a certificate from 'someone' in China and such possible security implications and
b) with Symbian Online signing BETA I have only ever managed to get ONE freeware app to work from it onto my i8910. All the other attempts (including DrJukka's new clock app - I think I will write to him and tell hime my probs). My i8910 still reports some certificate error of one kind or another, even after having been 'successfully' online signed over at Symbian Online. I've tried resetting my i8910 clock, all those tricks, and my i8910 is also set in the App Manager that I have allowed 'All' apps, and no Online Cert checking. I've also tried FreeSigner, etc. all to no avail.
Could it be that Symbian online BETA does not fully understand my i8910? I note online that some of the menu dialogues that other users report e.g. for the N95, are different as to how you find them on the i8910.
So there are obvious differences between N95 and 5800/i8910 v5 menus.
I understand the security reasons why signing exists, but I have never wasted such time with WinMo (ever) and never had (yet) any probs with my WinMo handset in 3 years of its use. Looks like I will have to set aside another weekend to understand signing *sigh*. I've found loads of webpages on how to get a certificate, but it all looks so flakey (some of the OPDA sites don't work) that I don't think I can take the risk with my i8910 handset I need everyday for professional use.