Unregistered wrote:The arguments against Xenon are well known and have been discussed plenty here before and are yet to be answered. As for making a difference every time... LOL I wonder what the auto mode is for then? Why not have permanent flash? Next time I am taking a photo of the sea from a high vista with the bright sun behind me I'll be sure to force the flash on to improve the shot....or in a stadium grandstand when I am trying to photograph the arena, because I want a dozen well backs of head in the shot and a dark arena.
Duh.
How about instead of sprouting stupid rubbish you use your superior knowledge and answer me this then...
On a phone with only LED 'flash', even the very best incarnation of this, explain to me how you would shoot the following scene in order to end up with a photo of acceptable results...
The aforementioned seaside scene you describe perhaps... a Spanish beach for example, warm, but fairly overpowering late afternoon/evening sun, BEHIND and to the side of the subject, a person standing in the shade of a palm tree...
Tell me how you would take a photo of that on an LED phone, and end up with a shot that has the required perfect balance of natural bright background light that the sun provides, but also in-fill forced flash to illuminate the very darkly shaded features of the subject's face.
Believe me, LED 'flash' will do NOTHING to help a scene such as that, and if you think any different, you haven't even come close to picturing the conditions I am describing.
For such a scene though, a phone with Xenon flash, such as my N82, would handle these issues flawlessly...
And this is just one single example of what I mean.
I could ask you to picture another scene, with night time portrait shots with a level of background light, but no lighting for the subject.
In such cases, LED will be not bright enough (because of the software exposure adjustment the phone will be doing due to the reasonably bright background objects and lighting), the beam it produces would be too focused, rather than dispersed, and the LED flash, due to its natural technical limitation, that of speed, would mean that the subject, even if they could stay still enough (see my previous post), would not matter in these cases, as the background sharp detail would be BLURRED itself, due to the slower than Xenon (a lot slower) shutter speed.
Why, oh why, oh why, do people keep building themselves up for these falls...
Again, I CHALLENGE you - if you know of a way to get around all these problems that LED bring, please, enlighten us...
Or stop wasting our time with lack of knowledge...
ALL of these things being ones I can happily take with my N82, but never my N86, even with it's variable aperture lens (which does try to help, but hey, let's keep the playing field LEVEL here, if that's the case, can you imagine what an N82 with a variable aperture lens would be able to do, and add in twin LED for video recording underneath, and what kind of phone would that be then).
Wow.
And yet people still say Xenon is not needed.
But never ever explain HOW they would shoot all these sorts of scenes though, funnily enough!