KPOM wrote:Would Nokia have shipped the N900 without the ability to make a call? What about the ability to send an SMS? They managed to port or write e-mail, basic navigation, music playing, contact management, and calendar applications, but not MMS. Apparently they think they can sell the phone in the meantime without MMS but with those features.
What, you mean like Apple did with the iPhone, and managed to sell TWENTY MILLION before they finally brought out MMS...?
A bit like that you mean...?
*lol*
And who said they wrote or ported ALL of that - in so far as I know, MOST of those things you list, are part of Maemo, or Maemo was at least designed to make that sort of application easy to code, perhaps unlike MMS which Maemo had zilch background with.
Disclaimer - I agree, it SHOULD have it. But all your post does is shows you ain't read MY post. NO they would not have brought out the N900 using Maemo, if at the time they needed to get it out the door, it could not make a phone call. Making a phone call is an ESSENTIAL part of a telephone after all. Nokia however have unlike us, took the view that MMS is a highly desirable aspect of a mobile phone, but not an ESSENTIAL feature, at least to a NEW PLATFORM like this, that is!
Nokia have made no secret that the Maemo is a Multimedia Computer, WITH THE ABILITY to make phone calls too. They have not at any point said "Hey, this is no different to any previous Nokia you might have held" - in fact far far from it, they have been at pains to point out, to the tech community at least, that, "We like the idea of this, but be careful, here there be dragons...".
MMS is just one single example of some the unique differences between the N900, and Symbian based Nokias, there are more however.
Once Nokia can code up, to their sufficient satisfaction, a proper MMS feature for Maemo, then we will not only see it rolled out retrospectively (my opinion at least), it will also of course come in the base code out the box, of any future Maemo Nokia devices.
Clearly, you haven't read my posts, as it is ME in here that is arguing tooth and nail that MMS is a vital feature - were six LONG posts claiming this, not enough for you 😉
But if you listen to half the members up above, you'd be forgiven for thinking MMS can be removed from ALL phones.
Certainly however, given that Nokia STILL do not have a suitable MMS client for the N900, let me ask you this...
"Would you rather Nokia had held off from releasing the N900 until they can get an MMS client sorted for it, which in simple terms, would mean that the N900 would in that situation, not even be out yet, and all those who own one, would still not own it...?"
That's a very real question, as that is what the situation would be.
And saying that, the question is not "Would you rather..." but should actually be asked as "Do you think that overall, the vast majority of people would rather Nokia had held off from...."
And we know the answer to that.
Like I said at the start, TWENTY MILLION iPhones sold before that device had MMS.... I think Nokia were entitled to release the N900 without MMS support, if it meant avoiding holding up the device unnecessarily. REMINDER - this was an EXPERIMENTAL release by Nokia, just to see what demand would be like. As such, for a new, experimental device, never before used, utilising an entirely new OS platform, and one not specifically designed for Telephony at that, then Nokia were well within their right to release it with any number of omitted features that did not exist for it, that other devices take for granted. That's the whole idea of an 'experimental release' of a new platform product.
Indeed, ONLY because of the huge surprise demand, would I feel Nokia are even now minded to create an MMS client. Otherwise I think they would have just left Maemo as it was, with a full openness to potential owners of any Maemo based device, that "Maemo does not support MMS, xyz, abc, etc. It is a Multimedia PC that also allows telephony".
So be thankful it has sold as well as it has. As this means two thinks - Nokia were RIGHT to release it without MMS, as demand was still more than high enough for a device with no MMS support.
And secondly, due to said high demand and sales, they are more likely to actually write an MMS client for it now.
Hope that clarifies, and I genuinely wish you every luck that Nokia are not far from getting you a great MMS client, as well as the new Nokia Maps with free life navigation too, rest assured sir.